Bufferbloat grades explained

The grade is how much your ping rises while your line is busy downloading or uploading: A under 20 ms, B under 50 ms, C under 100 ms, D under 200 ms, F at 200 ms or more. Competitive games need a B or better and video calls a C or better. A D or F means any download in the house will make games and calls lag, and it's usually fixable at the router.

The scale

Grade Ping rise under load What it feels like
A Under 20 ms Ping barely rises under load.
B 20 to under 50 ms A small rise; most people won't notice.
C 50 to under 100 ms Noticeable lag while something else downloads or uploads.
D 100 to under 200 ms Games and calls suffer whenever the line is busy.
F 200 ms or more Severe bufferbloat: any download or upload makes everything lag.

This is our own scale, and the verdict uses it as written. Other bufferbloat tests use their own scales and their own ways of loading the line, so a grade from another site won't always match ours.

How the grade is worked out

  1. The test measures your ping at rest: the middle value of about 20 round trips to the nearest Cloudflare location.
  2. It then downloads and uploads, and keeps pinging during each transfer: a ping roughly every 0.4 seconds while data moves.
  3. It takes the typical (median) ping during the download and during the upload, and keeps the larger of the two.
  4. The grade comes from how far that rose above the ping at rest. A rise can't go below zero.

So ping 20 ms at rest, 45 ms during the download and 160 ms during the upload is a rise of 140 ms: grade D. The upload decided it, which is common, since most home plans have far less upload than download.

What each grade means for you

  • A: Your router or provider keeps queues short. Someone can stream or download while you play, and you won't feel it.
  • B: Fine for everything, including competitive games (our limit for gaming is B). You might notice a small bump in a fast game during a big upload.
  • C: Calls still work (our limit for calls is C), but competitive games will feel late whenever the line is busy. Worth fixing if you play.
  • D: Games and calls lag whenever anyone else uses the connection heavily: a game update, a cloud backup, a video upload. The test tells you to fix bufferbloat first.
  • F: Any large transfer makes everything lag, often by hundreds of milliseconds. Fixing this usually helps more than any other change, including a faster plan.

Streaming isn't judged on the grade: the player buffers ahead, so a busy line rarely interrupts it.

Why ping rises under load

When more data arrives than your line can send, the extra waits in a queue, usually in your modem or router. Some equipment keeps very large queues. Large queues keep the line busy, but every packet behind them waits too, including your game's and your call's small packets. That wait is bufferbloat.

A faster plan doesn't remove it; the queue still fills, just at a higher speed. What fixes it is a router that keeps the queue short, usually by limiting the speed slightly below your plan's and sharing it fairly between connections. That feature goes by names such as smart queue management (SQM). The bufferbloat fix guide walks through the settings.

A worked example

Say the bufferbloat test shows:

  • ping at rest 18 ms;
  • ping during download 34 ms;
  • ping during upload 251 ms.

The rise is 251 − 18 = 233 ms, so the grade is F. The download side alone would be an A (16 ms). The upload is the problem: something fills the upload queue, which is typical on cable plans with a small upload. Turning on smart queue management at the router, with the upload limit set a little below the measured upload speed, is the usual fix. Run the test again afterwards; on many connections the grade moves to A or B.

Getting a reliable grade

  • Pause other heavy use in the house while you test, or the result reflects their traffic too.
  • Test on a cable if you can. Wi-Fi adds its own delays and makes the grade noisier.
  • Run it two or three times. The grade can move by a letter between runs, especially near a boundary.
  • Faster than about 1 Gbps? The test may not fill your line completely, so it may show a better grade than a full load would.